Inside Ajax’s Collapse: What’s Gone Wrong in Amsterdam?

Explore the recent decline of Ajax Amsterdam and uncover the tactical, financial, and leadership issues affecting one of the league’s most iconic clubs.
Ajax’s Struggles: What’s Gone Wrong in Amsterdam?
Ajax Amsterdam, long seen as the crown jewel of Dutch Spribe Aviator, is synonymous with youth development, attacking brilliance, and continental pedigree. However, the 2023/24 and 2024/25 seasons have exposed cracks in the very foundation that once made Ajax a European model of footballing excellence.
From boardroom turmoil to defensive collapses and a stalled youth pipeline, Ajax’s recent decline has left fans wondering: What went wrong? In this deep dive, we examine the root causes of the club’s struggles and why one of the most historic clubs in any league is facing an identity crisis.
A Club Built on Legacy and Philosophy
Ajax has always stood apart in the league for several reasons:
-
Total Football Origins under Rinus Michels and Johan Cruyff
-
Youth Academy Excellence (De Toekomst)
-
Clear football identity: possession, pressing, vertical movement
-
Self-sustainable model through player sales and smart recruitment
But the very strengths that made Ajax a European benchmark have recently become its weaknesses.
1. Leadership Crisis: Chaos at the Top
One of the most significant factors behind Ajax’s decline has been instability in the club’s leadership:
-
Marc Overmars’ departure due to scandal left a vacuum in sporting direction
-
Multiple managerial changes, with inconsistent philosophies
-
Poor executive decisions on signings and contract renewals
The lack of continuity in the boardroom has filtered down to the pitch, creating confusion over tactics, identity, and vision.
2. Poor Transfer Decisions and Recruitment
In recent years, Ajax’s transfer activity has drawn criticism:
-
Overpaying for underwhelming talent (e.g., Francisco Conceição, Calvin Bassey)
-
Selling stars without replacing them adequately (e.g., Martínez, Antony, Timber)
-
Loss of scouting edge compared to past years
The club’s once-lauded model of buying cheap, developing, and selling high has faltered. Instead, Ajax is now seen as paying more and gaining less—a worrying shift for a club defined by smart business in the league.
3. Youth Academy Pipeline Stalling
Ajax’s youth system, De Toekomst, has produced elite players like Frenkie de Jong, Matthijs de Ligt, and Donny van de Beek. But recent seasons have shown:
-
Fewer breakout stars transitioning into the first team
-
Increased pressure on young players to immediately perform
-
Disconnect between academy training and first-team philosophy
While players like Kenneth Taylor and Devyne Rensch show promise, they haven’t yet hit the star levels expected of Ajax graduates.
4. Tactical Identity Crisis
Under Erik ten Hag, Ajax thrived on a dynamic pressing system with positional fluidity. Since his departure:
-
Managers have failed to replicate that identity
-
Systems keep changing—3 at the back, 4-3-3, or 4-2-3-1
-
Players appear confused, roles unclear, and intensity missing
This inconsistency has resulted in a drop in possession stats, pressing efficiency, and overall rhythm—a death sentence for a club that lives and dies by its style.
5. Defensive Vulnerabilities
One of Ajax’s most glaring weaknesses has been its defense:
-
High line without cohesion, leading to counterattacks
-
Mistakes from center-backs and full-backs
-
Lack of a dominant goalkeeper since André Onana’s departure
Ajax has gone from one of the most defensively solid teams in the league to one conceding regularly—even against mid-table Eredivisie sides.
6. Fan Discontent and Media Pressure
As expectations remain sky-high, fans and media have been ruthless:
-
Public protests against board members
-
Banner displays demanding transparency
-
Pundits criticizing the club’s deviation from its roots
The weight of legacy has turned into a burden for the current squad, many of whom are still learning what it means to play under the Ajax spotlight.
What the Data Says (2023/24 Season)
Metric | 2021/22 | 2023/24 |
---|---|---|
Average Possession (%) | 63% | 54% |
Points After 20 Games | 48 | 28 |
Goals Conceded (Total) | 27 | 42 |
Players Used in Rotation | 22 | 33 |
Shots on Target per Game | 6.8 | 4.3 |
These numbers reflect a sharp decline in consistency, control, and clarity.
Can Ajax Turn It Around?
The good news for Ajax fans is that the club still retains its:
-
World-class academy system
-
Historic reputation that attracts talent
-
Financial strength relative to other Eredivisie sides
-
Passionate and demanding fanbase
To recover, Ajax must:
-
Stabilize leadership with a long-term sporting director and head coach
-
Refocus on youth development, not expensive experiments
-
Reestablish a clear tactical philosophy—even if results take time
-
Trust the process, even through short-term growing pains
Conclusion: A Giant Needs Rebuilding
Ajax’s struggles are not just about bad form—they’re the result of a system losing its identity. For a club with such a proud tradition, revival won’t be quick or easy. But it’s possible. If Ajax can re-center its values, trust its youth, and fix its structural flaws, it can once again rise to the top of the league and beyond.
⚽ Back Ajax’s Return to the Top of the League!
Support one of football’s most historic clubs as it rebuilds for the future. Stay loyal, stay loud, and show that Ajax’s DNA still runs strong in the heart of the league.
Leave a Comment